PD Smith

The Baseball Player and the Atom Bomb

08 October 2007 | Atomic Age, atomic bomb, Berg, cold war, Einstein, Hahn, Heisenberg, Reviewing, SF, spies | 8 comments

In the 1920s and 30s, Mor­ris “Moe” Berg was a Major League Base­ball play­er. He start­ed out with the Brook­lyn Dodgers in 1923 and fin­ished in 1939 with the Boston Red Sox. Despite the length of his career, by all accounts he was noth­ing spe­cial as a base­ball play­er.

Moe Berg

In Decem­ber 1944, Moe found him­self in the audi­to­ri­um of the Zurich Poly­tech­nic where a rebel­lious Ein­stein had once stud­ied (one of his lec­tur­ers described him as a “lazy dog” for his fail­ure to attend maths class­es). On the stage that day was Wern­er Heisen­berg, one of the cen­tral fig­ures in the Nazi atom­ic bomb pro­gram, and Moe Berg was lis­ten­ing intent­ly to what he was say­ing.

Moe was no fool. The six-foot one-inch tall base­ball play­er had shone in his first appear­ance on the radio quiz show Infor­ma­tion Please in 1938. A reg­u­lar on the show lat­er said he was the “most schol­ar­ly pro­fes­sion­al ath­lete” he’d ever met. At Prince­ton, Moe had stud­ied sev­en lan­guages, includ­ing San­skrit. But it was Ger­man he need­ed that day in Zurich.

Despite his undoubt­ed lan­guage skills, it’s unclear how much of Heisen­berg’s abstruse dis­cus­sion of S‑matrix the­o­ry Moe Berg actu­al­ly under­stood. After all, he was­n’t a physi­cist. But what is clear is that Heisen­berg did­n’t men­tion the atom bomb. For if he had, the base­ball play­er from Newark would have reached into his pock­et, tak­en out a .45 pis­tol, and shot him dead.

For Moe Berg — code­name ‘Remus’ — was an oper­a­tive of the OSS, the Office of Strate­gic Ser­vices, Amer­i­ca’s first cen­tral intel­li­gence agency. His mis­sion that day was to kill Heisen­berg if he gave even the slight­est hint dur­ing his lec­ture that the Nazis were close to build­ing an atom­ic bomb. For­tu­nate­ly for the quan­tum the­o­rist, they weren’t and the .45 stayed in Moe’s pock­et.

It’s an extra­or­di­nary sto­ry — one of many moments of indi­vid­ual brav­ery now con­signed to the his­to­ry books of the atom­ic age. I came across it while read­ing the new paper­back edi­tion of Jef­frey T Richel­son’s Spy­ing on the Atom­ic Bomb, a fas­ci­nat­ing and detailed account of Amer­i­ca’s strug­gle to force the nuclear genie back into the bot­tle. Berg’s exploits take up just a few pages of Richel­son’s impres­sive study which brings the sto­ry of pro­lif­er­a­tion right up to date with the lat­est intel­li­gence assess­ment on Iran’s atom­ic ambi­tions. His book reveals the secret his­to­ry of spies and nuclear sci­ence that gov­ern­ments have in the past tried to keep hid­den from their cit­i­zens.

Of course, in the Cold War most peo­ple were well aware of the threat from atom­ic weapons. Pop cul­ture was full of ref­er­ences to the atom­ic age: fall­out, H‑bombs (as well as C‑bombs and N‑bombs), Geiger coun­ters, radioac­tiv­i­ty, megadeaths, and Dooms­day Machines — this was the vocab­u­lary of mass destruc­tion that filled the news­pa­pers and air­waves.

The A‑word fea­tured in count­less film titles, from Cana­di­an Moun­ties vs the Atom­ic Invaders (1953) to The Atom­ic Man (1956). Giant radioac­tive ants and dinosaurs ram­paged across cin­e­ma screens. And in the first James Bond film, Dr No (1962), spies and mad atom­ic sci­en­tists came togeth­er in a cin­e­mat­ic for­mu­la that would prove a peren­ni­al suc­cess at the box-office.

Atomic Man

As well as B movies about the A‑bomb, chil­dren played with their toy Geiger coun­ters and ate atom­ic fire ball can­dy. There were zap­py atom­ic ray guns and, for the seri­ous atom­ic nerds, there was the atom­ic ener­gy lab, with real sam­ples of ura­ni­um ore. (Can you imag­ine the teacher’s reac­tion today if one of her kids came up and said, “Hey, miss, Susie has stolen my ura­ni­um!”?)

But for the adults, there was always the fear nag­ging in the back of their minds about what to do if the sirens sound­ed. Would gov­ern­ment advice on how to “Pro­tect and Sur­vive” or “Duck and Cov­er” real­ly be any good? One gov­ern­ment spon­sored book On How to Sur­vive an Atom­ic Bomb, pub­lished in 1950, gave sar­to­r­i­al advice for Dooms­day: women should wear stock­ings and long-sleeved dress­es, and men should wear wide-brimmed hats.

Gerstell 1950

For those who did­n’t swal­low the offi­cial pro­pa­gan­da, there were oth­er fanatasies. Such as the sur­vival­ist dream of return­ing to a fron­tier exis­tence after the bombs had fall­en and soci­ety had dis­solved into a Mad Max world. It was a warped dream that spawned atom­ic erot­i­ca and even post-nuclear porn — books like Jane Gal­lion’s Bik­er (1969) and George Smith’s The Com­ing of the Rats (1961).

Rats 1964

Today ref­er­ences to atom­ic or nuclear imagery have large­ly dropped out of pop cul­ture. In fact, when they do appear, nukes are more like­ly to be sav­ing the plan­et than destroy­ing it, as in films like Armaged­don (1998) or Sun­shine (2007). The Cold War and the Atom­ic Age seem like ancient his­to­ry to a new gen­er­a­tion — stuff peo­ple tell you in school. Few real­ly believe any more that “This Could Hap­pen Tomor­row!”.

Per­son­al­ly, I was nev­er a great fan of the Atom­ic Ener­gy Lab. But, as books like Richel­son’s show, the nukes are still out there — in the UK and the US as well as Iran and Rus­sia. We might not be so obsessed with them, but they haven’t gone away. And as Pres­i­dent Putin gloats over the launch of a new mis­sile that can hit a tar­get 3,800 miles away with pin-point accu­ra­cy, the head­lines are once again speak­ing of a new Cold War. We may need peo­ple like Moe Berg soon­er than you think.

[also post­ed on TNB]

8 comments so far:

  1. LiteraryMinded | 08 October 2007

    Inter­est­ing as always PD, thank you. I have always been fas­ci­nat­ed by the ‘duck and cov­er’ aspect. It seems ludi­crous now 🙂

    Angela

  2. PD Smith | 09 October 2007

    Thanks Angela. Yes, good old Bert the tur­tle is quite a star…!

  3. David Thorpe | 15 October 2007

    Love­ly foot­note. Lots more exam­ples of ear­ly gaffs in John May’s Green­peace Guide to the Nuclear Age, if you can get a copy.

  4. PD Smith | 16 October 2007

    Thanks David!

  5. indeterminacy | 03 November 2007

    I chanced in here (via lit­er­ary mind­ed) and was quite hap­py to find such an inter­est­ing post.

    A com­mon theme of radio plays of the time (40’s/50’s) was the destruc­tion of the Earth visa atom­ic weapons. In “LIghts Out”: a chain reac­tion destroys the atmos­phere, viewed by a group of sci­en­tists return­ing from a trip to the moon

    In “Dimen­sion X”: Aliens are mon­i­tor­ing Earth and wait­ing to destroy it upon fir­ing of the first atom­ic bomb. This plot­line recurred in sev­er­al dif­fer­ent ver­sions.

    If you#re inter­est­ed in obtain­ing mp3s of some of these, drop me a line and I’ll send them to you some­how.

    I’m too young to remem­ber duck and cov­er, but going to ele­men­tary school in the 60’s we did some­times have air raid drills in which we had to duck under the desk, and ball up with our hands behind our head for pro­tec­tion.

    This cool song “Kul­turelle Rev­o­lu­tion” by Felix Kubin uses a sound clip of the “Duck and Cov­er” sound­track:

    http://www.gagarinrecords.com/artists/felixkubin/av.php

  6. PD Smith | 04 November 2007

    Thanks very much for that com­ment — very inter­est­ing! Apart from Mer­cury The­atre’s “War of the Worlds” I have to admit I did­n’t real­ly explore radio productions…there’s such a wealth of mate­r­i­al out there though & it’s great to know some­one else is watch­ing out for them! By the way, Mer­cury The­atre has a great site with MP3s… http://www.mercurytheatre.info/

    Always hap­py to know of more sites with links to atom­ic age mate­r­i­al — let me know and I’ll add them to my rapid­ly increas­ing page of links…

  7. indeterminacy | 04 November 2007

    You’re wel­come. I know the link 😉 A lot of the sci­ence fic­tion series are avail­able now at archive.org. The spe­cif­ic atom­ic sto­ries I know of are: Dimen­sion X (Out­er Lim­it), X Minus 1 (remake of Out­er Lim­it), Beyond Tomor­row (Inci­dent at Switch­path), Lights Out (The Rock­et Ship).

    2000 Plus and Explor­ing Tomor­row were oth­er sci-fi series, but I’m not sure of the indi­vid­ual sto­ries.

    Then there was an inter­est­ing series which tried to pre­dict the future of atom­ic ener­gy “The Fifth Horse­man” from 1946 (also at archive.org).

  8. PD Smith | 05 November 2007

    Many thanks for those — archive.org is a fan­tas­tic resource. Any­one inter­est­ed in watch­ing atom­ic age clips should go to their mov­ing image sec­tion and search for ‘atom­ic’. Some chill­ing stuff…

    Let me know if you find oth­ers! Cheers.